Benefit Boutique Lash Tint
Not a product but an in-store service provide at Benefit Boutiques nationwide. For less than $25, you get four weeks of looks-like-mascara lashes - without mascara. The service takes less than 25 minutes and it really is noticeable. I was told it works better on lighter colored eyes but regardless, it's worth a try! $21 at Benefit.com. Search store locations for the boutique near you.